Home · Food · Everyday living

Hot Cocoa Mix in a Jar: Recipe, Layers and a Printable Label

Several pint Mason jars of layered hot cocoa mix with marshmallows, tied with twine and blank kraft tags, on a wooden table

For hot cocoa mix in a jar, stir 1 1/2 cups instant nonfat dry milk, 1/3 cup sugar, 1/4 cup plus 2 tablespoons baking cocoa and 1/2 cup mini marshmallows together, then fill a pint jar. Each mug takes 1/2 cup of mix and 1 cup of hot water or milk. Those are the Toll House pint amounts, and they make four mugs.

I keep a shelf of empty jars for exactly this kind of gift. A jar of cocoa costs a few dollars to fill, and nobody’s ever handed one back! The tag is the piece that makes it a real gift, so I’ll walk you through that too.

Hot Cocoa Mix in a Jar Recipe

This is the pint version. It fills one 16-ounce Mason jar and makes four mugs, which is plenty for a gift. You don’t need anything fancy, just a bowl, a spoon and a funnel if you’ve got one.

  • 1 1/2 cups instant nonfat dry milk
  • 1/3 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/4 cup plus 2 tablespoons unsweetened baking cocoa
  • 1/2 cup mini marshmallows (optional)
  • A pinch of salt, if you like the chocolate flavor to pop

Here’s the catch. Those amounts add up to about 2 3/4 cups when you measure them loose, and a pint jar holds 2 cups to the brim. So you can’t layer by the listed amounts and expect it all to fit.

Stir everything except the marshmallows in a bowl first. Spoon the mix into the jar, tap it on the counter, and press the marshmallows in on top.

Whatever’s left over goes into a small jar for your own kitchen, which my picky eater considers the best part of gift-making.

How Many Mugs Fit in Each Jar Size?

A 4-ounce jar holds one mug of mix, an 8-ounce jar holds two, and a pint holds four. That follows from 1/2 cup of mix per mug, and the jar sizes are nominal volumes.

Jar sizeMix it holdsMugs
4 ozabout 1/2 cup1
8 oz (half pint)about 1 cup2
16 oz (pint)about 2 cups4

Need the amounts for a smaller jar? Scale the Toll House pint recipe down by simple division, since the mix is the same in every mug. These are my own divisions of the published amounts.

  • 8-ounce jar (2 mugs): 3/4 cup dry milk, 2 2/3 tablespoons sugar, 3 tablespoons cocoa, 1/4 cup mini marshmallows
  • 4-ounce jar (1 mug): 6 tablespoons dry milk, 1 1/3 tablespoons sugar, 1 1/2 tablespoons cocoa, 2 tablespoons mini marshmallows

One 4-ounce jar is a good teacher’s gift or a stocking filler. The Pioneer Woman fills four of them per batch, with 2 tablespoons of sugar, 1 tablespoon of cocoa, 2 tablespoons of dry milk, a tablespoon of shaved chocolate and 12 mini marshmallows in each.

Want a two-mug jar instead? thehomecookskitchen uses an 8-ounce jar with 4 tablespoons of cocoa, 4 tablespoons of sugar and 1/2 tablespoon of cornstarch, topped with chocolate chips. That one has no dry milk, so whoever gets it stirs it into hot milk.

How Do You Layer the Jar, and What Goes on the Label?

Layer from the bottom up with sugar first, then cocoa, then dry milk, and finish with the marshmallows on top. The tag you tie on matters more than the layers.

Wipe the inside of the glass with a dry paper towel between layers so the lines stay clean. The layers get stirred away the moment someone opens the jar.

Here’s the wording I put on a printable label or a plain index card:

  1. Pour the jar into a bowl and stir well.
  2. Scoop 1/2 cup of mix into a mug.
  3. Add 1 cup of hot water or hot milk and stir.
  4. Top with the marshmallows. Keep the rest tightly covered.

Notice that the label says to stir in the mug, not in the jar. Why does that matter? A Reddit thread about a cracked glass cup makes the reason plain:

“Glass meant for thermal shock is borosilicate. Lab glass, French press, and mugs intended for hot liquids. Typical soda-lime glass will crack with sudden temperature changes.”
– r/tifu (59 upvotes)

So the jar is for storing and gifting only. You’ll want to pour boiling water into a regular mug, and add a line to the tag so nobody gets a surprise.

Pint Mason jar of layered hot cocoa mix with marshmallows, tied with twine and a blank tag, next to a mug
Illustration: a pint jar of layered hot cocoa mix ready to give as a gift.

If you’re printing the label, give it four lines you can read at a glance: the name of the mix, the directions above, a note that says “Contains milk,” and the date you filled it. Leave a blank line for the date so you can write it by hand. Add “Stir in the mug, not the jar” at the bottom in bold.

How Much Sugar and Cocoa Goes in Each Mug?

Three popular recipes differ more per mug than they do per jar. Dividing each batch by its stated servings gives sugar of about 1 1/3 tablespoons for Toll House, 2 tablespoons for the Pioneer Woman and about 2 2/3 tablespoons for Wholefully, whose batch uses powdered sugar and makes 12 servings.

Cocoa runs about 1 1/2 tablespoons per mug at Toll House, 1 tablespoon at the Pioneer Woman and about 1 2/3 tablespoons at Wholefully. Those are my own divisions of their published amounts, and the servings differ a little, so they’re a rough guide.

Bar chart of sugar per mug in tablespoons: Toll House 1.3, Pioneer Woman 2, Wholefully 2.7

What does that mean for you? The Toll House mix is the least sweet and leans on dry milk for body. Wholefully’s is the sweetest and has chocolate chips, so it tastes like dessert.

If your kids drink theirs plain, start with the Toll House amounts. If it’s too bitter for them, a spoonful more sugar in the mug fixes it without redoing the jar.

How Long Does Hot Cocoa Mix Keep?

The NDSU Extension pantry storage chart (FN579, reviewed January 2023) gives cocoa mixes a year, covered tightly. Treat that as the ceiling for your jar.

Dry milk and marshmallows carry their own dates on the package, so you should write the earliest one on the tag.

Use a jar with a tight lid and keep it in a cool, dry cupboard, away from the stove. Moisture is what turns powder into a brick.

This isn’t a canning recipe. Grandma Florence canned her green beans and tomatoes, but dry mix needs no processing at all, and you shouldn’t put a filled cocoa jar in a water bath or an oven. Just fill it, close it and shelve it.

Is Hot Cocoa Mix the Same as Hot Chocolate Mix?

The names get used loosely, and every recipe I’ve quoted here is built on cocoa powder. So a jar labeled hot cocoa mix and one labeled hot chocolate mix can be the same thing. If you swap in chopped chocolate for part of the cocoa, like the shaved chocolate in the Pioneer Woman jars, you get a richer cup.

Whichever name you put on the tag, the directions stay the same. Add hot liquid to the mix in a mug and stir.

Can You Swap Ingredients or Spend Less?

Yes, and most of the swaps save you money, because the two costly items are dry milk and cocoa. You can leave out the milk powder, change the sweetness or use a cheaper jar, and the gift still works.

  • No dry milk: Keep the sugar and cocoa, drop the milk powder, and tell the receiver on the tag to stir it into hot milk instead of water.
  • Dairy-free: Use a plant-based milk powder if you can find one, and read the label for what else is in it.
  • Mexican style: Add a little cinnamon to the dry mix, and a tiny pinch of cayenne for adults.
  • Less sweet: Cut the sugar by a tablespoon and let people add more at the mug.
  • Cheaper jars: Reuse clean pasta sauce jars for the mix, or look for dollar store jars with metal lids.

Buy dry milk and cocoa in bigger containers and fill several jars at once, since you’ll use the same scoop for each. My picky eater skips the marshmallows, so I tuck them into a small bag on top of the lid instead. Isn’t it nice when a gift works for the fussy one too?

If you want more jar gifts in the same line, try the layered cookie mix in a jar for a quart-size present, or the snowman hot chocolate jar for a cute way to dress up the lid. I also keep my flour and sugar in the same jars, as in these Mason jar canisters, so the cupboard and the gift shelf share one supply.

Last step: print the label, tape it to the jar, and tie a spoon on with twine. That’s it, you’re done!