Crumbl is famous for its rotating selection of cookies that change every week. With so many creative options, one thing fans love to talk about is which flavors are the best. Whether you’re new to Crumbl or a long-time fan, knowing the most popular picks from the Crumbl Cookies menu can help you decide what to try next—or make you wish your favorite comes back soon.
In this article, we’ll walk through Crumbl’s all-time fan-favorite cookies. We’ll look at the classics, the seasonal stars, and the surprise hits that got people talking (and drooling!).
What Makes a Crumbl Cookie Flavor “Popular”?
Crumbl doesn’t just randomly choose which cookies become stars. Flavors become favorites based on:
- High weekly sales
- Customer reviews and social media buzz
- Repeated returns to the menu
- Fan demand via the Crumbl app or Instagram comments
Some cookies show up nearly every month. Others might only come back once a year—but cause a frenzy when they do.
The Most Loved Crumbl Cookie Flavors (Ranked)
These flavors are the top picks among Crumbl fans, both in sales and popularity:
1. Milk Chocolate Chip
- Why it’s loved: Classic, warm, and gooey with a thick, soft center.
- Appears almost weekly.
- Crumbl’s version uses milk chocolate instead of semi-sweet for a creamier taste.
Fun Fact: This is the only cookie that’s on the menu almost every week.
2. Chilled Sugar (Pink Frosted)
- Why it’s loved: A chilled vanilla sugar cookie topped with signature pink almond frosting.
- Soft, sweet, and nostalgic—it’s one of Crumbl’s most iconic looks.
3. Cookies & Cream Milkshake
- A chilled cookie with Oreo pieces, vanilla frosting, and more Oreo crumbs on top.
- Creamy, cold, and satisfying like a real milkshake.
4. Snickerdoodle Cupcake
- A soft snickerdoodle base topped with whipped cinnamon frosting.
- Combines two classic treats in one cookie.
5. Chocolate Oreo
- Rich chocolate cookie with Oreo crumbs baked in.
- Often topped with Oreo buttercream—a fan obsession.
This cookie sells out quickly when it’s on the menu.
6. Peanut Butter Munch (feat. Muddy Buddies®)
- Tastes like a chewy, peanut butter version of the famous cereal snack.
- Topped with powdered sugar and crispy pieces.
7. Key Lime Pie
- A chilled graham cracker cookie topped with creamy lime filling and whipped cream.
- Fans love it for its balance of tart and sweet.
8. Birthday Cake
- A funfetti-style cookie with buttercream frosting and rainbow sprinkles.
- Comes in different versions (Birthday Cake Vanilla, Chocolate, and Oreo).
9. Chocolate Cake
- Rich chocolate base topped with fudge frosting and chocolate curls.
- Loved by chocoholics everywhere.
10. Lemon Glaze or Lemon Poppy Seed
- Light, citrusy, and fresh—perfect for spring and summer menus.
- Great choice for fans who prefer less sweetness.
Table: Top 10 Crumbl Flavors & Their Popularity Score
| Rank | Cookie Flavor | Popularity Score (Fan Votes + Returns) |
| 1 | Milk Chocolate Chip | ★★★★★ |
| 2 | Chilled Sugar (Pink) | ★★★★★ |
| 3 | Cookies & Cream Milkshake | ★★★★☆ |
| 4 | Snickerdoodle Cupcake | ★★★★☆ |
| 5 | Oreo Cookie | ★★★★☆ |
| 6 | Peanut Butter Munch | ★★★★☆ |
| 7 | Key Lime Pie | ★★★★☆ |
| 8 | Birthday Cake | ★★★★☆ |
| 9 | Chocolate Cake | ★★★☆☆ |
| 10 | Lemon Glaze | ★★★☆☆ |
Note: Popularity based on Crumbl app reviews, Reddit cookie threads, and repeat menu appearances.
How Often Do Fan-Favorite Cookies Come Back?
Crumbl has a habit of bringing popular cookies back every few weeks or during special occasions. Here’s what usually happens:
- Monthly rotation: Some cookies return every 3–4 weeks.
- Holiday or seasonal returns: Cookies like Pumpkin Roll or Eggnog appear around fall or Christmas.
- By fan request: Crumbl listens to social media, app reviews, and direct feedback.
Why These Cookies Go Viral on Social Media
Crumbl fans love to:
- Post photos of the weekly box
- Review cookies on TikTok or YouTube
- Rank the week’s flavors
Cookies like Birthday Cake and Chilled Sugar are very “Instagrammable,” which helps their popularity grow even more.
What About the Most Underrated Cookies?
While the cookies above are well-known, some low-key favorites also deserve attention:
- Buttermilk Pancake – Tastes like breakfast in a cookie.
- Cornbread Honey Butter – A warm and sweet-savory twist.
- French Silk Pie – A whole dessert in cookie form.
- Molten Lava – Hot, gooey, and filled with melted chocolate.
New Flavors vs. Fan Favorites
Each week, Crumbl usually balances the menu with:
- 1–2 returning fan-favorites
- 2–3 brand-new or seasonal cookies
- 1 classic staple (usually Milk Chocolate Chip)
This keeps things fresh while still giving customers something familiar.
Where to Stay Updated on Your Favorite Flavors
Since Crumbl’s cookies rotate weekly, it can be easy to miss your favorite. To make sure you stay updated:
- Check Crumbl’s app or website every Sunday night
- Follow their Instagram (@crumblcookies)
- Or visit trusted menu update sites like CrumblCookiesWeekMenu.us for:
- This week’s Crumbl Cookies menu
- Next week’s expected cookies
- Last week’s flavor archive
- This week’s Crumbl Cookies menu
Final Thoughts
With hundreds of flavors rotating each year, Crumbl has built a cookie culture that’s fun, exciting, and constantly changing. From warm Milk Chocolate Chip to chilled Cookies & Cream, fans have strong opinions—and favorites they can’t wait to see again.
If you’ve never tried some of these cookies, keep checking the weekly menus. You never know when your dream flavor will return to the Crumbl Cookies menu!
Leave a Reply